FondationFAM Numérique 5ème cycleNumérique 5ème cycle
DonateDons
Chapitre 8Chapter 8 Part 3 · Towards a multilateral third way Partie 3 · Vers une troisième voie multilatérale

Identified patterns

Translated from the French, which remains the reference text. This translation is under review.

Introduction: A pattern language

There is an illustrious precedent for what we sketch here. Confronted with the irreducible diversity of natural commons — fisheries, irrigation systems, forests — Elinor Ostrom did not produce a general theory: she extracted from the comparative analysis of cases eight design principles, abstract enough to travel from one commons to another, concrete enough to guide action. That work earned her the Nobel Prize; above all, it gave the commons their grammar.

Our conviction, at the close of this first part, is that the time has come to do for digital infrastructure commons what Ostrom did for resource commons. The natural format for such work would be a pattern language, in the sense Christopher Alexander gave the term: for each tension identified, a fiche — the context, the forces at play, the resolution operator or operators (stratification, alternation, thirdness, bootstrapping, metabolism), The invariant under test: the cases of embodiment: Indian and European, and the counter-example of failure that marks its limits. Such a referential, built jointly by the architects of the two continents — and here we find again the residencies proposed in the conclusion of this report —, would be far more than an academic deliverable: it would be the shared toolkit of convergence, the common language in which a unique third way can be written by several hands.

One precaution, to finish, that Morin himself imposes on us. The method he calls for is not a programme — it is, he says, a path built by walking it. A pattern language is an aid to judgement, not a substitute: the day these five operators hardened into an algorithm, the day the dialogic froze into procedure, the variety they are meant to cultivate would begin to die. Complexity is not administered; it is gardened. It is to that gardening — patient, equipped, multilateral — that the remainder of this mission might contribute.